DiscGolfWarrior.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. As an affiliate, this website earns from qualifying purchases.
Are you looking for a midrange disc to add to your bag? Something you can throw off the tee or from the fairway? Something maneuverable that will hold any line you put on it?
Well Discraft has nearly a dozen options to choose from, covering the spectrum from overstable to understable, faster to slower, beaded or unbeaded.
The focus of this article is two specific Discraft midranges, the Discraft Comet vs. Buzzz.
The Buzzz is one of Discraft’s most popular discs, comes in several varieties, and can be found in the bag of no less than Paul McBeth.
But the Comet has been getting a lot of attention lately, and Michael Johansen’s successful use of this disc in the pro circuit has only added to the hype. So at the end of the day, which disc should you bag?
Let’s take a look at how that Comet and the Buzzz stack up.
Not all Buzzzes are created equal
Before we get into the direct comparison of the Buzzz and the Comet, we should be clear which Buzzz we are talking about.
With a turn of -1, the classic Buzzz is significantly more stable than the Comet, which has a turn rated at -2.
And the Buzzz OS, the most overstable disc in the Buzzz lineup, has a turn of 0 and has very little in common with the Comet.
So if you’re looking for a more stable midrange disc you may want to consider one of these discs instead.
Paul McBeth provides this great rundown of many of Discraft’s midrange discs.
However, there is one version of the Buzzz that is very similar to the Comet in many aspects, and that is the SS.
Both the Buzzz SS and the Comet have a turn of -2, as well as comparable speed ratings and similar functionality.
For this reason we’ve decided to focus the majority of this article on a comparison of the Discraft Comet and the Buzzz SS.
Speed, Glide and Feel
As we mentioned above, the Buzzz SS and the Comet have identical turn ratings of -2.
This means that both discs will fly very straight and will hold any angle you throw them on.
The only exception to this is fade; both discs are rated with a fade of 1 and will drop off reliably in the last few feet of a throw.
So what separates these two discs?
The first difference is speed.
The Buzzz SS can handle a bit more speed than the Comet can, so this may make the SS preferable for players who like to throw their midrange discs hard, or players with higher arm-speed in general.
Conversely, the Comet has more glide than the SS, making it more suitable for players looking to gain some extra distance or for players with naturally lower arm-speed.
But these differences are fairly subtle, and in terms flight and performance the SS and the Comet are very similar discs.
The biggest difference between them comes down to feel. For players used to other discs in the Buzzz series, the SS should feel comfortable and familiar.
This is a classic beadless midrange disc, despite a small difference in feel as compared to the standard Buzzz.
The Comet on the other hand has a very unusual feel, which players seem to either love or hate.
The rim on the Comet is fairly narrow and beaded, and the overall diameter of the disc is larger than that of the SS.
The Comet is especially suited to short touchy shots or wooded holes, and it’s been on these holes that pro MJ has used the Comet with great results.
The SS may be better suited to slightly longer shots, and is especially good for players who have already used other models of the Buzzz and like the way it feels.
So at the end of the day, what makes the difference between these two discs, beyond a touch more speed for the SS, a touch more glide for the Comet, is a significantly different feel that these two discs have.
You can view the Discraft ESP Buzzz SS Midrange Golf Disc at Amazon to learn more about how it might work for you.
For more information, you can view the Discraft Comet Elite Z Golf Disc at Amazon.
Discraft Comet vs Buzzz SS: Which is right for you?
So which of these two midrange discs should you go with? Let’s take a minute to sum up the numbers on each of them.
With the Comet, you’ll get a speed rating of 4, a glide of 5, a turn of -2 and a fade of 1.
With the Buzzz SS, you’ll get a slightly higher speed rating of 5, a slightly lower glide rating of 4, and identical turn and fade, -2 and 1 respectively.
But as we said before, what really sets these discs apart is how they feel in your hand and on the release.
With top-level pros endorsing both of these discs, it’s clear that either one would be a great option for your own game.
Your best bet is to try throwing both to decide which disc feels best for you!
Featured image credit: DepositPhotos.com